Hello dear
Welcome To Maya's Mexican Grill
At Maya's Mexican Grill, we take pride in serving authentic Mexican cuisine in a warm, community-focused atmosphere. Located in Shelbyville, Indiana, we blend traditional flavors with a modern touch, evident in dishes like our sizzling Molcajete and flavorful Enchiladas Suizas. Our restaurant stands out not just for the food, but for our welcoming staff, who treat every guest like family. Customers adore our unique salsa bar and homemade desserts, which elevate the dining experience. From hearty tacos to the famous tableside guacamole, each dish reflects our commitment to quality and love for Mexican culture, making us a beloved local favorite.
About
Maya's Mexican Grill
Welcome to Maya's Mexican Grill, a hidden gem nestled at 2505 Indiana 130 #44 in Shelbyville, IN. This beloved local haunt has quickly earned a devoted following and is often regarded as the family-favorite Mexican restaurant in town. More than just a place to grab a meal, Maya's is a celebration of authentic Mexican flavors served with a personal touch.
At Maya's Mexican Grill, the menu is a vibrant tapestry of classic dishes. From the satisfying Hard and Soft Tacos to the tempting Taco Supreme, priced at just $2.95 to $3.90, every bite promises a burst of flavor. If you're a fan of salads, don’t miss their Taco Salad or the Fajita Taco Salad, beautifully presented in a crispy tortilla bowl and brimming with fresh ingredients at $13.99 and $15.60 respectively. And for lovers of enchiladas, Maya’s offers a delightful variety, including the Enchiladas Suizas and Enchiladas Blancas, both priced at $14.30.
- Customer Reviews:
- Judith Heck: Praised the beef chimi and noted that while the bean dip wasn't to her taste, the salsa bar made up for it.
- Jenna Martin: Adored the friendly staff who make diners feel like family, and highlighted the perfect blend of Americanized and authentic Mexican cuisine.
- Hannah Fisher: Rated it 10/10 and appreciated the fast service, despite the bustling environment.
- Destiny Holt: Gave a special shoutout to the amazing tableside guacamole.
- Steve H: Enjoyed the unique twist of creamy, cheesy refried beans paired with a selection of fresh salsas from the salsa bar.
The ambiance at Maya's is cozy and intimate, making it an ideal spot for families and friends to gather. As you dine, you'll notice the restaurant’s unique support for the local equine community, with themed decor that reflects the rich culture of horse racing in the region. This sense of community is mirrored in the way the staff treats their guests—like family.
And if you think you might skip dessert, think again! The owner crafts homemade Mexican desserts that are said to be simply mouthwatering, ensuring you leave with a sweet memory of your visit.
With its flavorful food, engaging atmosphere, and community spirit, Maya's Mexican Grill is not just a meal—it's an experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and indulge in the best of Mexican cuisine. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ It was my first visit, but my family's favorite Mexican restaurant in town. The food (beef chimi) was great. I wasn't a fan of the bean dip/salsa served with the chips because I don't care for beans, but the salsa bar more than made up for it. My dining partners (my lovely parents) love the bean dip. I'll go back when I'm in town. ”
“ Mayas is a family-favorite from day one! The staff are like family (kind, ask about your day, remember your name, and give you a hard time when you need it- ha!). In a community that has plenty of Mexican restaurants to choose from, Maya’s has a good balance of Americanized Mexican cuisine and authentic dishes for a diverse palated group. The dining experience is quaint (small dining room), great attention and timely service, and the food presentation is perfect. They support the local equine community and sport their horses and jockey’s on the wall and consistently display live horse racing on the television. In the horse racing capital of the region, it’s a perfect balance of community support and celebration. If you are a family that typically doesn’t order dessert, you will change your tune here! The owner makes homemade, Mexican dessert dishes that are mouthwatering! Made fresh and never frozen (unless it’s ice cream), you will enjoy a taste from home- made with love! ”
“ 10/10. It was a little strange that they bring refried beans (but like a creamy, cheesy refried beans) and not salsa with chips, but a fun, different twist. The food came fast and it was very busy, which is an obvious sign of popularity. ”
“ Best place to eat with great service! Definitely try out the tableside guac! It’s amazing!! ”
“ Bean dip was a pleasant free addition to the normal chips and salsa. Serve yourself your choice of 5 salsas from the salsa bar. Each salsa choice tasted fresh and flavorful. Dishes shown are the chimichanga and chili relleno. I added a little of the salsa verde to my rice before taking the picture. All good flavor and glad we stopped in. ”
“ Best margaritas in town. My personal favorite is their new hibiscus margarita... DELICIOUS! Food is always so good. 100 % recommend. Service is quick and polite always! ”
“ Cute hole in the wall Mexican restaurant. Salsa bar was excellent and the bean dip set up was unique and delicious. Tried a carne en su jugo, supreme. ”
“ My food was absolutely fantastic! I’ve eaten here multiple times and loved everything that I’ve gotten! The staff is quick and they take care of all of their customers. I got Quesabirria on this trip and they were so stuffed that I couldn’t eat more than one! ”